Pages

Showing posts with label Ben Nelson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ben Nelson. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Blanche Balks at Reconciliation

Unless Blanche Lincoln has more up her sleeve, I guess we can assume this is her big announcement:
Sen. Blanche Lincoln (D-AR) will oppose Dem efforts to move health care legislation through Congress using budget reconciliation, hurting Dems' chances for using the controversial parliamentary maneuver to pass a reform bill.

"I am opposed to and will fight against any attempts to push through changes to the Senate health insurance reform legislation by using budget reconciliation tactics that would allow the Senate to pass a package of changes to our original bill with 51 votes," Lincoln said in a statement on Tuesday. "I have successfully fought for transparency throughout Senate deliberations on health care, and I will continue to do so."

"I will not accept any last-minute efforts to force changes to health insurance reform issues through budget reconciliation, and neither will Arkansans. We have worked too long and too hard on this reform effort - we need to get it right," she said.
I have to have a little chuckle at her claim she successfully fought for transparency, did she do that on CSPAN?   I might have missed that.   Lincoln's vote for the Senate health care bill has her in trouble with her fellow Arkansans, a point not lost on the powers that be in the DSCC who have been rumored to be pressuring her to retire.  Earlier today she announced  she had over $5 million on hand in her campaign coffers.  Lincoln appears to be posturing here hoping to convince her constituents she gets the message while sending a message to Democrats they won't be getting rid of her that easily.

Lincoln's announcement confirms rumors Democrats continue to pursue alternate paths to health care legislation despite a clear message from voters in Massachusetts to put the brakes on.  If Democrats were to attempt reconciliation the bill would either need to be pared down to strictly budgets items such as tax increases or medicaid cuts in order to bypass the need for 60 votes.  This would leave the bill finally passed full of holes that would fail to meet the intended purpose of the legislation.  There is no budgetary effect to a health insurance mandate, for example, which would be challenged endlessly as inappropriate for inclusion in a budgetary procedure.


If Democrats were able to trim down the bill only to its budgetary elements, Lincoln's vote would not be necessary since the procedure requires only 51 votes.  Perhaps she is signaling the abandonment of the reform by other key moderates such as Evan Bayh and Ben Nelson.  Still, voters in their home states are already well aware their Senators voted for the unpopular reform.  Much of this appears to be political theater though we should give some kudos for the transparency of their efforts.  Exit stage right...

Thursday, January 21, 2010

Despair, Disarray and Secret Relief - Oh My!

Josh Marshsall at TPM posted an email he received from a Senate staffer, anonymous natch, who laments the odd sense of relief amidst the despair at the sudden realization of their fate come November. Here's the highlight:
The worst is that I can't help but feel like the main emotion people in the caucus are feeling is relief at this turn of events. Now they have a ready excuse for not getting anything done. While I always thought we had the better ideas but the weaker messaging, it feels like somewhere along the line Members internalized a belief that we actually have weaker ideas. They're afraid to actually implement them and face the judgement of the voters. That's the scariest dynamic and what makes me think this will all come crashing down around us in November.

If they only had a brain they would have been listening to their constituents who have been screaming at the top of their lungs enough already. Instead they lined up to cast their votes for the horrific health care legislation that grew increasingly more unpopular every day. Still, I have to believe the likes of Blanche Lincoln, Evan Bayh and Ben Nelson would secretly be quite relieved to know they might have an out instead of casting another fateful vote for the dreaded bill.

Lincoln and Nelson have seen their job approval numbers tumble in recent days.  Lincoln currently "enjoys" a 38% job approval with 34% favorability.  Nelson has been booed in restaurants and other public events.  Others, including Barney Frank were so stunned by the results they all but declared the health care bill dead.  Ding Dong!  Ironically one of the districts that voted heavily for Brown was the same one where Frank must seek reelection, how sad.  After a good stiff drink of Dem Kool Aid, however, Frank walked back his strong remarks..  Here's the walk back:
In an interview with TPMDC this evening, Rep. Barney Frank (D-MA) reversed course--apologizing for a harsh statement he released last night in the wake of the Massachusetts special election, and saying, explicitly, that if he's assured the bill will be fixed down the line, he'd vote for the Senate health care bill.

"I'm easy. I'm strongly inclined to vote for the thing, even though I don't like the health care tax thing," Frank told me. "But you know, I was ready to vote for the bill when I had people on the left yelling at me not to vote for it. So you know I'll vote for any of it... to try and move the process along."
He's easy.  That must be some Kool Aid they serve in the Democrat's canteen.

The rest of the staffer's email is a rather long history of the failures of the Democrats to pass legislation the staffer knew to be far better than Republican alternatives.  It appears the current group may be following the same path despite the fact they enjoyed unprecedented majorities.   The staffer seems to believe they dragged their feet and now they despair:
It was disheartening when it seemed that Reid was allowing McConnell's disingenuous narrative of "it's always taken 60 votes to get anything done" to take hold, but we were later even saved from that when Specter switched. But it seems we've spent the entire year moving our own goalposts farther away. Things have gotten so bad that in roaming the halls today it feels exactly as if we lost the Majority last night.
Could it be they didn't have enough confidence in their own policies to even entertain the notion they could convince Repulicans to come aboard?  While that is possible, we certainly saw an awful lot of hubris over the past year, particularly in the House.  Now they know they face certain losses in November, some Democrats in denial may have convinced themselves voters will forget between now and then.  I certainly wouldn't bet on that but plunging ahead to pass policies some Democrats seem to doubt is certain suicide.  Should be an interesting 10 months or so watching them wait it out.

Saturday, December 19, 2009

They Have the Votes - Nelson Had a Price

From the Washington Post:
The last best hope to prevent Democrats from passing this train wreck, Senator Nelson, discovered his vote could be bought after all:

"We're there," said Sen. Kent Conrad (D-N.D.), as he headed into a special meeting to outline the deal.

Democratic leaders spent days trying to hammer out a deal with Nelson, and worked late Friday night with him on abortion coverage language that had proved the major stumbling block. Nelson also secured other favors for his home state.

Under the new abortion provisions, states can opt out of allowing plans to cover abortion in insurance exchanges the bill would set up to serve individuals who don't have employer coverage. Plus, enrollees in plans that do cover abortion procedures would pay for the coverage with separate checks - one for abortion, one for rest of health-care services.

Nelson secured full federal funding for his state to expand Medicaid coverage to all individuals below 133 percent of the federal poverty level. Other states must pay a small portion of the additional cost. He won concessions for qualifying nonprofit insurers and for Medigap providers from a new insurance tax. He also was able to roll back cuts to health savings accounts.
The Other McCain notes this may be the first time the term "30 pieces of silver" appears in federal legislation.  How true.  Nelson received a letter earlier in the week from the Governor of Nebraska asking Nelson not to vote for the bill as the state was unable to afford its portion of the Medicaid expansion in coverage.  Nelson's pretense he was holding out for stricter language on abortion appears to have been nothing more than elaborate kabuki waiting for the desperate Democrats to come up what will likely be hundreds of millions for his state.  As Ed Morrissey notes:
After that, Nebraskans get as screwed as the rest of the country.
Here is the Managers Amendment:
Managers Amendment height="500" width="100%" > value="http://d1.scribdassets.com/ScribdViewer.swf?document_id=24315049&access_key=key-1artidjjhocumhxhhybt&page=1&version=1&viewMode=list">            


CSpan 2 is currently covering a full reading of the amendment which is expected to take until 3 PM this afternoon. It's looks as though there is not much left in the arsenal to stop this awful legislation from being passed out of the Senate on Christmas eve of all days. As Sean Trende writes in "Real Clear Politics" this bill is political suicide for the Democrats though they continue to delude themselves they have found their Holy Grail:
I don't think they're close to finding their Grail. I think the better analogy is probably that they're close to their Moby Dick. And we all know what happens to Captain Ahab once he finally harpoons his white whale.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
 
Web Analytics